|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
||||
|
|
||||
|
||||
University of Georgia
In 2003, Congress passed the Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act, which required that in 2006 the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) implement a system of competitive bids to set payments for the Medicare Advantage program. Managed care plans now bid for the right to enroll Medicare beneficiaries. Data from the first year of bidding suggest that imperfect competition is limiting the success of the bidding system. This article offers suggestions to improve this system based on findings from auction theory and previous government-run auctions. In particular, CMS can benefit by adjusting its system of competitive bids in four ways: credibly committing to regulations governing bidding; limiting the scope for collusion, entry deterrence, and predatory behavior among bidders; adjusting how benchmark reimbursement rates are set; and accounting for asymmetric information among bidders.
Achman, Lori, and Marsha Gold. 2004. Medicare Advantage 2004 Payment Increases Resulting from the Medicare Modernization Act. Report, Mathematica Policy Research, February 17. www.mathematica-mpr.com/publications/PDFs/MedAvpayrates.pdf.
Berenson, Robert A. 2004. Medicare Disadvantaged and the Search for the Elusive "Level Playing Field." Web exclusive, Health Affairs, December 15. content.healthaffairs.org/cgi/content/full/hlthaff.w4.572/DC1.
Biles, Brian, Lauren Hersch Nicholas, and Barbara S. Cooper. 2004. The Cost of Privatization: Extra Payments to Medicare Advantage Plans—2005 Update. Issue brief, Commonwealth Fund, December. www.cmwf.org/usr_doc/750_Biles_costofprivatization_update_ib_pdf.pdf.
Blum, Jonathan, Jennifer Bowman, and Chiquita White. 2005. The Impact of Enrollment in the Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit on Premiums. Kaiser Family Foundation, October. www.kff.org/medicare/7423.cfm.
Burner, Sally. 2005. Understanding Medicare Advantage Bidding and Payment: Effects on Plan Choice and Beneficiary Premiums. Paper presented at the National Health Policy Forum Session, April 28.
Butler, Stuart M. 2003. The Crucial Elements of an Acceptable Medicare Bill. Heritage Foundation Backgrounder, July 16.
Caplan, Craig F., and Lisa A. Foley. 2000. Structuring Health Care Benefits: A Comparison of Medicare and the FEHBP. American Association of Retired Persons (AARP) Policy Institute Research Report No. 2000-05, May.
Cawley, John, Michael Chernew, and Catherine McLaughlin. 2005. HMO Participation in Medicare+Choice. Journal of Economics and Management Strategy 14: 543-574.[CrossRef]
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). 2004a. Principles for Establishing Medicare Advantage Regions to Maximize Access to High-Quality Regional Plans. www.mahp.org/Policy/medicare/mmaregions/MA%20Region%20Methodology%20Dec%2006%2004.pdf.
____. 2004b. Establishment of the Medicare Advantage Program. Proposed Rule CMS-4069-P (RIN 0938-AN06), August 3.
____. 2005a. Medicare Managed Care Manual. Department of Health and Human Services Publication 100-16, rev. 68, September 2. www.cms.hhs.gov/Manuals/IOM/itemdetail.asp?filterType=none&filterByDID=-99&sortByDID=1&sortOrder=ascending&itemID=CMS019326.
____. 2005b. Medicare Drug Premiums Will Be Lower than Expected: Consumer Choice, Competition Will Help Beneficiaries. CMS Fact Sheet, August 9. www.cms.hhs.gov/apps/media/press/release.asp?Counter=1530.
____. 2005c. Multiple Bid Submissions for Medicare Advantage and Prescription Drug Plans. May 4. Washington, DC: Department of Health and Human Services. www.cms.hhs.gov/PrescriptionDrugCovContra/Downloads/D_multiplebidposting.pdf.
____. 2005d. Medicare Program: Establishment of the Medicare Advantage Program. 42 CFR Parts 417 and 422. Federal Register 70 (19): 4589.
____. 2006. 2006 Bid Submission User's Manual. Washington, DC: Department of Health and Human Services.
Cooper, Barbara S., and Bruce C. Vladeck. 2000. Bringing Competitive Pricing to Medicare. Health Affairs 19 (5): 49-54.[CrossRef][Medline]
Dowd, B., J. Christianson, R. Feldman, C. Wisner, and J. Klein. 1992. Issues Regarding Health Plan Payments under Medicare and Recommendations for Reform. Milbank Quarterly 70: 423-453.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Dowd, B., R. Coulam, and R. Feldman. 2000. A Tale of Four Cities: Medicare Reform and Competitive Pricing. Health Affairs 19 (5): 9-27.[Abstract]
Dowd, Bryan E., Roger Feldman, and Jon Christenson. 1996. Competitive Pricing for Medicare. Washington, DC: American Enterprise Institute.
Feldman, Roger, Kenneth E. Thorpe, and Bradley Gray. 2002. Policy Watch: The Federal Employees Health Benefits Plan. Journal of Economic Perspectives 16 (2): 207-217.[ISI][Medline]
Gaynor, Martin, and Deborah Haas-Wilson. 1999. Change, Consolidation, and Competition in Health Care Markets. Journal of Economic Perspectives 13(1): 141-164.[ISI][Medline]
Gold, Marsha. 2006. The Landscape of Private Firms Offering Medicare Prescription Drug Coverage in 2006. Kaiser Family Foundation, March. www.kff.org/medicare/upload/7474.pdf.
Gray, Tom. 2001. From the Golden Age to the Crackdown Stage: Are We to Blame for the Reimbursement Climate? HomeCare, October.
Hackbarth, Glenn M. 2004. Letter to Mark McClellan, Administrator, CMS, re: File Code CMS-4069-P, October 4. www.medpac.gov/publications/other_reports/100404_ptc_SH_comment.pdf.
Harris, Milton, and Artur Raviv. 1981. Allocation Mechanisms and the Design of Auctions. Econometrica 49: 1477-1499.[CrossRef][ISI]
HealthLeaders-Interstudy. 2005. Humana Announces Plans for Regional Medicare PPOs in Georgia, Alabama, South Carolina, and Tennessee. News release, Decision Resources, May 23. home.healthleaders-interstudy.com/index.php?p=press-archive-detailed&pr=pr_05232005.
Hoerger, Thomas, Richard Lindrooth, Kevin Tate, Shulamit Bernard, Teresa Waters, Ann Meadow, and Sarita Karon. 2003. Competitive Bidding for Medicare Services: Interim Evaluation Results. Presentation at AcademyHealth Annual Research Meeting, June 28, Nashville, TN.
Humana. 2005. Humana's Array of Medicare Advantage Plans for 2006 Will Offer Those Eligible for Medicare More Options and Choices. News release, Humana Corporate Communications, September 29. www.humana.com/corporatecomm/newsroom/releases/PR-News-20050929-170155-NR.html.
Institute of Medicine (IOM). 2006. Medicare's Quality Improvement Organization Program: Maximizing Potential. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
Kaiser Family Foundation. 2006. Medicare Health and Prescription Drug Plan Tracker. www.kff.org/medicare/healthplantracker/index.jsp (accessed July 26, 2006).
Karon, Sarita, Kay Jewell, Thomas Hoerger, Shulamit Bernard, Eric Finkelstein, Kevin Tate, Richard Lindrooth, and Teresa Walters. 2002. Evaluation of Medicare's Competitive Bidding Demonstration for DMEPOS [Durable Medical Equipment, Prosthetics, Orthotics, and Supplies]: Second-Year Annual Evaluation Report. CMS Contract No. 500-95-0061/T.O. No. 3, April.
Klemperer, Paul. 2002. What Really Matters in Auction Design. Journal of Economic Perspectives 16 (1): 169-189.[CrossRef][ISI]
Knittel, C. R., and V. Stango. 2003. Price Ceilings as Focal Points for Tacit Collusion: Evidence from Credit Cards. American Economic Review 93: 1703-1729.[CrossRef][ISI]
Laffont, Jean-Jacques, and Eric Maskin. 1980. Optimal Reservation Price in the Vickery Auction. Economics Letters 6: 309-313.[CrossRef][ISI]
Laschober, M. A., P. Neuman, M. S. Kitchman, L. Meyer, and M. Langwell. 1999. Medicare HMO Withdrawals: What Happens to Beneficiaries? Health Affairs 18 (6): 150-157.[Abstract]
MedPAC. 2004. Report to Congress: Medicare Payment Policy. March. Washington, DC: MedPAC. www.medpac.gov/publications/congressional_reports/Mar04_Entire_reportv3.pdf.
Milgrom, Paul R. 1985. The Economics of Competitive Bidding: A Selective Survey. In Social Goals and Social Organizations, ed. Leonid Hurzicz, David Schmeidler, and Hugo Sonnenschein. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Myerson, Roger B. 1981. Optimal Auction Design. Mathematics of Operations Research 6: 58-73.
NCMIC Insurance Company. 2003. Blues Threaten Exit from FEHBP over Proposed Accounting Change. Managed Care Overview Newsletter, January/February. www.ncmic.com/newsletters/MCO/2003/MCO1_03.htm.
Nichols, Len M. 2001. Lessons from the Competitive Pricing Advisory Committee Experience for the Medicare+Choice Program and Long Term Reform. Statement before the United States Senate Committee on Finance, April 3.
Nichols, Len M., and Robert Reischauer. 2000. Who Really Wants Price Competition in Medicare Managed Care? Health Affairs 19 (5): 30-43.[Abstract]
Pieratt, J. P. 2001. Legislating the HME Industry: Will Washington Lawmakers Ever Lighten Up? HomeCare, October.
Philpott, Tom. 2003. Are There Enough in the House? AIR FORCE Magazine, March, 46-49.
Posner, Michael. 2005. VA Negotiates Better Prescription Drug Deals than Medicare. GovExec.com, December 21. www.govexec.com/story_page.cfm?articleid=33064.
Raflo, Brook. 2002. Sunrise or Sunset? HomeCare, February, 2.
Riley, John G., and William F. Samuelson. 1981. Optimal Auctions. American Economic Review 71: 381-392.[ISI]
Rothkopf, Michael H. 1983. Bidding Theory: The Phenomena to Be Modeled. In Auctions, Bidding and Contracting: Uses and Theory, ed. Richard Engelbrecht-Wiggins, Martin Shubik, and Robert Stark, 105-120. New York: New York University Press.
Rothkopf, Michael H., and Ronald M. Harstad. 1994. Modeling Competitive Bidding: A Critical Essay. Management Science 40: 364-384.
Stigler, George. 1964. A Theory of Oligopoly. Journal of Political Economy 72: 44-61.[CrossRef][ISI]
Thaler, Richard. 1992. The Winner's Curse. In The Winner's Curse: Paradoxes and Anomalies in Economic Life, 50-62. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
U. S. Department of Defense. 1999. Section 733 Update: Report of the Working Group on Sustainment and Training. Office of Program Analysis and Evaluation, April. Washington, DC: Department of Defense.
____. 2001. Efficiency Analysis of Military Medical Treatment Facilities. Center for Naval Analysis Technical Report. Washington, DC: Department of Defense.
U.S. General Accounting Office (GAO). 2000. Medicare+Choice: Payments Exceed Cost of Fee-for-Service Benefits, Adding Billions to Spending. HEHS-00-161. Washington, DC: GAO.
____. 2002. Federal Employees' Health Plans: Premium Growth and OPM's Role in Negotiating Benefits. Report 03-236. Washington, DC: GAO.
U.S. House of Representatives. 2003. Medicare Prescription Drug, Improvement, and Modernization Act of 2003, Conference Report [to accompany H.R. 1], 108-391. Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office.
von Ungern-Sternberg, Thomas. 1991. Swiss Auctions. Economica, n.s., 58: 341-357.[CrossRef][ISI]
Weschler, Jill. 2005. Medicare Regions Please Large Insurers, but CMS Disappoints Some Local Plans in Drawing Medicare Map with Twenty-Six PPO Regions. Managed Healthcare Executive, January 1. www.managedhealthcareexecutive.com/mhe/article/articleDetail.jsp?id=141933.
Williams, David T. 2002. Competitive Bidding. HomeCare, April, 4.
W. R. Hambrecht and Co. n.d. OpenBook: Overview. www.wrhambrecht.com/comp/debt/overview.htm (accessed October 20, 2004).
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
