|
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
|
||||
|
|
||||
|
||||
Over the past twenty years, Medicare has been transformed from a single-payer insurer into a hybrid of complementary public and private insurance arrangements. Despite creating ongoing controversy, these changes have resulted in an ironic and largely overlooked strategic potential: Medicare's evolving hybrid form makes it the most promising vehicle for overcoming the historical obstacles to universal health insurance in the United States. To make this surprising case, we first explore the distinctive political dynamics of programs that, like today's Medicare, are hybrids of public and private arrangements. We then consider how these political dynamics might circumvent past barriers to universal health insurance. Finally, we discuss the strengths and weaknesses of alternative pathways through which Medicare could be expanded to promote health security.
Achman, Lori, and Marsha Gold. 2003. Medicare+Choice Plans Continue to Shift More Costs to Enrollees. New York: Commonwealth Fund.
Atherly, Adam, Paul L. Hebert, and Matthew L. Maciejewski. 2005. An Analysis of Disenrollment from Medicare Managed Care Plans by Medicare Beneficiaries with Diabetes. Medical Care 43: 500-506.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Barry, Colleen. 2004. Regulation and Innovation in Behavioral Health Care. PhD diss., Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
Berenson, Robert A. 2004. Medicare Disadvantaged and the Search for the Elusive "Level Playing Field." Web exclusive, Health Affairs, December 15. content.healthaffairs.org/cgi/content/full/hlthaff.w4.572/DC1.
Biglaiser, Glen, and David Brown. 2003. The Determinants of Privatization in Latin America. Political Research Quarterly 56: 77-89.
Blendon, Robert, and John Benson. 2001. Americans' Views on Health Policy: A Fifty-Year Historical Perspective. Health Affairs 20 (2): 33-46.
Blendon, Robert, Mollyann Brodie, John Benson, Drew Altman, Larry Levitt, Tina Hoff, and Larry Hugick. 1998. Understanding the Managed Care Backlash. Health Affairs 17 (4): 80-94.[Abstract]
Blumenthal, David, Joel Weissman, Melissa Wachterman, Evette Weil, Randall S. Stafford, James M. Perrin, Timothy G. Ferris, Karen Kuhlthau, Rainu Kaushal, and Lisa I. Iezzoni. 2005. The Who, What, and Why of Risk Adjustment: A Technology on the Cusp of Adoption. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 30: 453-473.[Abstract]
Boccuti, Christina, and Marilyn Moon. 2003. Comparing Medicare and Private Insurers: Growth Rates in Spending over Three Decades. Health Affairs 22 (2): 230-237.
Booske, Bridget, Judith Lynch, and Gerald Riley. 2002. Impact of Managed Care Market Withdrawal on Beneficiaries. Health Care Financing Review 24 (1): 95-115.[Medline]
Brodie, Mollyann, Elizabeth Hamel, Jaime Valdez, Robert Blendon, and John Benson. 2004. March/April 2004 Health Poll Report Survey. Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation.
Brown, Lawrence D., and Michael S. Sparer. 2003. Poor Program's Progress: The Unanticipated Politics of Medicaid Policy. Health Affairs 22 (1): 31-44.
Butler, Stuart. 1987. Changing the Political Dynamics of Government. Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science 36 (3): 4-13.[CrossRef]
Call, Katherine Tiede, Bryan Dowd, Roger Feldman, Nicole Lurie, Marshall A. McBean, and Matthew Maciejewski. 2001. Disenrollment from Medicare HMOs. American Journal of Managed Care 7: 37-51.[ISI][Medline]
Claxton, Gary, Isadore Gil, Ben Finder, Erin Holve, Jon Gabel, Jeremy Pickreign, Heidi Whitmore, Samantha Hawkins, and Cheryl Fahlman. 2004. Employer Health Benefits: 2004 Annual Survey. Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation.
Coalition for America's Children, the Tarrance Group, and Lake Research. 1995. Survey question USTARR.95CHLD.R14, July 18-19. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
____. 1996. Survey question USTARR.96CHLD.R058, December 5-8. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
Cook, Fay Lomax, and Edith Barrett. 1992. Support for the American Welfare State. New York: Columbia University Press.
Cook, Fay Lomax, Victor Marshall, Joanne Marshall, and Julie Kaufman. 1994. The Salience of Intergenerational Equity in Canada and the United States. In Economic Security and Intergenerational Justice, ed. Theodore Marmor, Timothy Smeeding, and Vernon Green, 91-129. Washington, DC: Urban Institute Press.
Dallek, Geraldine, and Andrew Dennington. 2002. Physician Withdrawals: A Major Source of Instability in the Medicare+Choice Program. New York: Comonwealth Fund.
Davis, Karen, Marilyn Moon, Barbara Cooper, and Cathy Schoen. 2005. Medicare Extra: A Comprehensive Benefit Option for Medicare Beneficiaries. Web exclusive, Health Affairs, October 4. content.healthaffairs.org/cgi/reprint/hlthaff.w5.442v2.
Davis, Karen, Cathy Schoen, Michelle Doty, and Katie Tenney. 2002. Medicare versus Private Insurance: Rhetoric and Reality. Web exclusive, Health Affairs, October 9. content.healthaffairs.org/cgi/reprint/hlthaff.w2.311v1.
Douglas, James. 1983. Why Charity? The Case for a Third Sector. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
Dowd, Bryan, Robert Coulam, and Roger Feldman. 2001. A Tale of Four Cities: Medicare Reform and Competitive Pricing. Health Affairs 19 (5): 9-29.
Eichner, Jane, and David Blumenthal, eds. 2003. Medicare in the Twenty-first Century: Building a Better Chronic Care System. Washington, DC: National Academy of Social Insurance.
Employee Benefit Research Institute and Matthew Greenwald and Associates. 1998. Survey question USMGA.98FEB.R5B. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
Fossett, James, Malcolm Goggin, John S. Hall, Jocelyn Johnston, L. Christopher Plein, Richard Roper, and Carol Weissert. 2000. Managing Medicaid Managed Care: Are States Becoming Prudent Purchasers? Health Affairs 19 (4): 36-49.[Abstract]
Freudenheim, Milt. 2006. Luring Customers from Medicare: Fee-for-Service Health Plans Flourish with Government Help. New York Times, September 22.
Fuchs, Beth. 2004. Expanding the Individual Health Insurance Market: Lessons from State Reforms of the 1990s. Research Synthesis Report No. 4. Princeton, NJ: Robert Wood Johnson Foundation.
Gazmarian, Julie A., David W. Baker, Mark V. Williams, Ruth M. Parker, Tracy L. Scott, Diane C. Green, S. Nicole Fehrenbach, Junling Ren, and Jeffrey P. Koplan. 1999. Health Literacy among Medicare Beneficiaries in a Managed Care Organization. Journal of the American Medical Association 281: 545-551.
Geyman, John. 2006. Shredding the Social Contract: The Privatization of Medicare. Monroe, ME: Common Courage.
Glavin, Mitchell P. V., Christopher P. Tompkins, Stanley S. Wallack, and Stuart H. Altman. 2002-2003. An Examination of the Factors in the Withdrawal of Managed Care Plans from the Medicare+Choice Program. Inquiry 39: 314-354.[ISI][Medline]
Gold, Marsha. 2006. The Growth of Private Plans in Medicare. Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation.
Gold, Marsha, Michael Sinclair, Mia Cahill, Natalie Justh, and Jessica Mittler. 2001. Monitoring Medicare+Choice: Medicare Beneficiaries and Health Plan Choice, 2000. Washington, DC: Mathematica Policy Research.
Goldstein, Judith. 1988. Ideas, Institutions, and American Trade Policy. International Organization 42: 179-217.[ISI]
Gordon, Colin. 2003. Dead on Arrival: The Politics of Health Care in Twentieth-Century America. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Grogan, Colleen, and Eric Patashnik. 2003. Between Welfare Medicine and Mainstream Entitlement: Medicaid at the Political Crossroads. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 28: 821-858.[Abstract]
Gross, Diane, Helena Temkin-Greener, Stephen Kunitz, and Dana Mukamel. 2004. The Growing Pains of Integrated Health Care for the Elderly: Lessons from the Expansion of PACE. Milbank Quarterly 82: 257-282.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Grossman, Joy M., Bradley Strunk, and Robert E. Hurley. 2002. Reversal of Fortune: Medicare+Choice Collides with Market Forces. Issue Brief No. 52. Washington, DC: Center for Studying Health System Change.
Hacker, Jacob. 1997. The Road to Nowhere. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
____. 2001. Medicare Plus: Increasing Health Coverage by Expanding Medicare. In Covering America: Real Remedies for the Uninsured, ed. E. K. Wicks, 73-100. Washington, DC: Economic and Social Research Institute.
____. 2002. The Divided Welfare State: The Battle over Public and Private Social Benefits in the United States. New York: Cambridge University Press.
____. 2004. Privatizing Risk without Privatizing the Welfare State: The Hidden Politics of Social Policy Retrenchment in the United States. American Political Science Review 98: 243-260.[CrossRef][ISI]
Hanoch, Yaniv, and Thomas Rice. 2006. Can Limiting Choice Increase Social Welfare? The Elderly and Health Insurance. Milbank Quarterly 84: 37-73.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Henig, Jeffrey. 1994. Rethinking School Choice: Limits of the Market Metaphor. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Hibbard, Judith, Jaquelyn Jewett, Siegfried Engelman, and Martin Tusler. 1998. Can Medicare Beneficiaries Make Informed Choices? Health Affairs 17 (6): 181-193.[Medline]
Hibbard, Judith, Paul Slovic, Ellen Peters, and Melissa Finucane. 2000. Older Consumers' Skill in Using Comparative Data to Inform Health Plan Choice: A Preliminary Assessment. American Association of Retired Persons (AARP) Public Policy Institute Research Report 2000-14. Washington, DC: AARP.
Hibbard, Judith, Paul Slovic, Ellen Peters, Melissa Finucane, and Martin Tusler. 2001. Is the Informed-Choice Policy Approach Appropriate for Medicare Beneficiaries? Health Affairs 20 (3): 199-203.
Hibbard, Judith, and E. Weeks. 1987. Consumerism in Health Care: Prevalence and Predictors. Medical Care 25: 1019-1032.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Howard, Christopher. 1993. The Hidden Side of the American Welfare State. Political Science Quarterly 108: 403-435.[CrossRef][ISI]
Jacobs, Lawrence R., and Robert Y. Shapiro. 1999. The American Public's Pragmatic Liberalism Meets Its Philosophical Conservatism. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 24: 1021-1031.[ISI][Medline]
____. 2000. Politicians Don't Pander: Political Manipulation and the Loss of Democratic Responsiveness. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Jacobs, Lawrence R., Robert Y. Shapiro, and Eli C. Schulman. 1993. Medical Care in the United States—An Update. Public Opinion Quarterly 57: 394-427.[Abstract]
Jencks, Stephen, Edwin Huff, and Timothy Guerdon. 2003. Change in the Quality of Care Delivered to Medicare Beneficiaries, 1998-1999 to 2001-2002. Journal of the American Medical Association 289: 305-312.
Johnson, Haynes, and David Broder. 1997. The System: The American Way of Politics at the Breaking Point. Boston: Little, Brown.
Johnston, Philip, and Nancy Turnbull. 2006. A Bold Insurance Experiment. Boston Globe, April 16.
Kain, John. 1983. America's Persistent Housing Crises: Errors in Analysis and Policy. Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 465 (January): 136-148.[Abstract]
Kaiser Family Foundation. 2001. Post-election Survey: The Public and the Health Care Agenda for the New Administration and Congress. Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation.
____. 2006a. January/February 2006 Health Poll Report Survey. Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation.
____. 2006b. Seniors' Early Experiences with the Medicare Prescription Drug Benefit—April, 2006. Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation.
Kaiser Family Foundation, Harvard School of Public Health, and Princeton Survey Research Associates. 2000. Survey question USPSRA.01PELEC.R23C. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
King, Kathleen M., and Mark Schlesinger, eds. 2003. The Role of Private Plans in Medicare: Lessons from the Past, Looking to the Future. Washington, DC: National Academy of Social Insurance.
Kleinke, J. D. 2005. Dot-Gov: Market Failure and the Creation of a National Health System Technology System. Health Affairs 24: 1246-1262.
Knapp, Michael S. 1987. Educational Improvement under the Education Block Grant. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis 9: 283-299.
Krasner, Jeffrey. 2006. Healthcare Reform Isn't A Done Deal... Until They Say It Is. Boston Globe, May 24.
Kronebusch, Karl, and Brian Elbel. 2004. Simplifying Children's Medicaid and SCHIP. Health Affairs 23 (3): 233-246.
Kronick, Richard, and Joy de Beyer. 1999. The Problem of Selection in Medicare Risk-Contract HMOs. In Medicare HMOs: Making Them Work for the Chronically Ill, ed. Richard Kronick and Joy de Beyer, 9-26. Chicago: Health Administration.
Kronick, Richard, David C. Goodman, John Wennberg, and Edward Wagner. 1993. The Marketplace in Health Care Reform—The Demographic Limitations of Managed Competition. New England Journal of Medicine 328: 148-152.
Ladd, Helen. 2002. School Vouchers: A Critical Review. Journal of Economic Perspectives 16 (4): 3-24.
Lake, Timothy, and Randall Brown. 2002. Medicare+Choice Withdrawals: Understanding Key Factors. Menlo Park, CA: Kaiser Family Foundation.
Laschober, Mary A., Patricia Neuman, Michelle S. Kitchman, Laura Meyer, and Kathryn M. Langwell. 1999. Medicare HMO Withdrawals: What Happens to Beneficiaries? Health Affairs 18 (6): 150-157.[Abstract]
Levy, Becca, and Mark Schlesinger. 2005. When Self-Interest and Stereotypes Collide: Older Individuals' Opposition to Federal Programs That Benefit Their Age Group. Journal of Aging and Social Policy 17: 25-39.[CrossRef]
Long, Sharon K., and Alshadye Yemane. 2005. Commercial Plans in Medicaid Managed Care: Understanding Who Stays and Who Leaves. Health Affairs 24: 1084-1094.
Louis Harris and Associates. 1967. Majority of U.S. Public Advocates Medicare for All, Not Just Elderly. Washington Post, January 23.
____. 1994. Survey question USHARRIS.060694.R1C, May 23-26. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
Maioni, Antonia. 1998. Parting at the Crossroads: The Emergence of Health Insurance in the United States and Canada. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Marmor, Theodore. 1973. The Politics of Medicare. Chicago: Aldine.
Masters, Robert, and Catherine Eng. 2001. Integrating Acute and Long-Term Care for High-Cost Populations. Health Affairs 20 (6): 161-172.
Mayes, Rick, and Robert Berenson. 2006. Medicare Prospective Payment and the Shaping of U.S. Health Care. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC). 2000. Improving Risk Adjustment in Medicare: A Report to the Congress. Washington, DC: MedPAC.
Miller, Robert, and Harold Luft. 2002. HMO Plan Performance Update: An Analysis of the Literature, 1997-2001. Health Affairs 21 (4): 63-86.
Miranda, Rowan, and Allan Lerner. 1995. Bureaucracy, Organizational Redundancy, and the Privatization of Public Services. Public Administration Review 55: 193-200.[CrossRef][ISI]
Moon, Marilyn, and Matthew Storeyguard. 2001. One-Third at Risk: The Special Circumstances of Medicare Beneficiaries with Health Problems. New York: Commonwealth Fund.
New York Times. 1968. No Presidential Candidate Favors Medicare for All at the Present Time. October 25.
____. 1970. Medicare for All Is Asked by Javits. April 15.
____. 1994. Mr. Stark's Race Backward. March 10.
____. 1998. Medicare Expansion. January 7.
Oberlander, Jonathan. 2000. Is Premium Support the Right Medicine for Medicare? Health Affairs 19 (5): 84-99.[Abstract]
____. 2003a. The Political Life of Medicare. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
____. 2003b. The Politics of Health Reform: Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good Plans? Web exclusive, Health Affairs, August 27. content.healthaffairs.org/cgi/reprint/hlthaff.w3.391v1.
Page, Benjamin I., and Robert Y. Shapiro. 1992. The Rational Public: Fifty Years of Trends in Americans' Policy Preferences. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Pear, Robert. 1994. Bill Passed by Panel Would Open Medicare to Millions of Uninsured People. New York Times, July 1.
Peters, Christie Provost. 2005. Medicare Advantage SNPs: A New Opportunity for Integrated Care? National Health Policy Forum Issue Brief No. 808, November 11. Washington, DC: George Washington University. www.nhpf.org/pdfs_ib/IB808_SNP_11-11-05.pdf.
Princeton Survey Research Associates. 1996. Survey question USPSRA.PS96CHLAT. R37, July 26 - September 5. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
Quadagno, Jill. 2005. One Nation Uninsured: Why the United States Has No National Health Insurance. New York: Oxford University Press.
Rice, Thomas. 1999. Should Medicare Managed Care Plans and Medigap Policies Have a Coordinated Open Enrollment Period? In Medicare HMOs: Making Them Work for the Chronically Ill, ed. Richard Kronick and Joy de Beyer, 109-132. Chicago: Health Administration Press.
Roland, Gerard. 2002. The Political Economy of Transition. Journal of Economic Perspectives 16 (1): 29-50.[CrossRef][ISI]
Rosenfeld, Raymond A. 1979. Local Implementation Decisions for Community Development Block Grants. Public Administration Review 39: 448-457.[CrossRef][ISI]
Schiltz, Michael E. 1970. Public Attitudes toward Social Security, 1935-1965. Research Report No. 33. Washington, DC: U.S. Social Security Administration, Office of Research and Statistics.
Schlesinger, Mark. 1997. Paradigms Lost: The Persisting Search for Community in U.S. Health Policy. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 22: 937-992.[ISI][Medline]
____. 2004. Reprivatizing the Public Household? Medical Care in the Context of American Public Values. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 29: 969-1004.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Schlesinger, Mark, and Richard Lau. 2000. The Meaning and Measure of Policy Metaphors. American Political Science Review 94: 611-626.[CrossRef][ISI]
Schneider, Eric, Paul Cleary, Alan Zaslavsky, and Arnold Epstein. 2001. Racial Disparities in Influenza Vaccination: Does Managed Care Narrow the Gap between African Americans and Whites? Journal of the American Medical Association 286: 1455-1460.
Schoen, Cathy, Elisabeth Simantov, Lisa Duchon, and Karen Davis. 2000. Counting on Medicare: Perspectives and Concerns of Americans Ages 50 to 70. New York: Commonwealth Fund.
Schoenman, Julie, Stephen Parente, Jacob Feldman, Mona Shah, William Evans, and Michael Finch. 2005. Impact of HMO Withdrawals on Vulnerable Medicare Beneficiaries. Health Care Financing Review 26 (3): 5-30.[ISI][Medline]
Shapiro, Robert Y., and John T. Young. 1986. The Polls: Medical Care in the United States. Public Opinion Quarterly 50: 418-428.[Abstract]
Sheils, John, and Randall Haught. 2003. Cost and Coverage Analysis of Ten Proposals to Expand Health Insurance Coverage. Washington, DC: Economic and Social Research Institute.
Silow-Carroll, Sharon, Jack A. Meyer, Marsha Regenstein, and Nancy Babgy. 1995. International Comparisons. In In Sickness and in Health? The Marriage between Employers and Health Care, 85-102. Washington, DC: Economic and Social Research Institute.
Skocpol, Theda. 1996. Boomerang: Health Care Reform and the Turn against Government. New York: W. W. Norton.
Starr, Paul. 1987. The Limits of Privatization. Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science 36 (3): 124-137.[CrossRef]
Stevens, Beth. 1988. Blurring the Boundaries: How the Federal Government Has Influenced Welfare Benefits in the Private Sector. In The Politics of Social Policy in the United States, ed. Margaret Weir, Ann Shola Orloff, and Theda Skocpol, 123-148. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Stuart, Bruce, Dennis Shea, and Becky Briesacher. 2001. Dynamics of Drug Coverage of Medicare Beneficiaries: Finders, Losers, and Switchers. Health Affairs 20 (2): 86-99.
Stuber, Jennifer, Geraldine Dallek, and Brian Biles. 2001. National and Local Factors Driving Health Plan Withdrawals from Medicare+Choice. Washington, DC: George Washington University Center for Health Services Research and Policy.
Stuber, Jennifer, and Mark Schlesinger. 2006. The Sources of Stigma for Means-Tested Government Programs. Social Science and Medicine 63: 933-945.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Temkin-Greener, Helena, Alina Bajorska, and Dana Mukamel. 2006. Disenrollment from an Acute/Long-Term Care Program (PACE). Medical Care 44: 31-38.[CrossRef][ISI][Medline]
Thompson, Lyke, and Richard C. Elling. 2000. Mapping Patterns of Support for Privatization in the Mass Public: The Case of Michigan. Public Administration Review 60: 338-348.[CrossRef][ISI]
Time Magazine, Cable News Network, and Yankelovich Partners. 1994. Survey question USYANKP.030794.R18D, March 2-3. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
Touhy, Carolyn. 1999. Accidental Logics: The Dynamics of Change in the Health Care Arena in the United States, Britain, and Canada. New York: Oxford University Press.
U.S. News and World Report. 1966. Medicare for All—How Near? July 4, 1.
Washington Post. 1968. No Presidential Candidate Favors Medicare for All at Present Time. October 25.
Weissman, Joel, Melissa Wachterman, and David Blumenthal. 2005. When Methods Meet Politics: How Risk Adjustment Became Part of Medicare Managed Care. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 30: 475-504.[Abstract]
Yankelovich, Daniel. 1995. The Debate That Wasn't: The Public and the Clinton Health Care Plan. Brookings Review 13 (3): 36-411.[Medline]
Zogby International. 2003. Survey question USZOGBY.03MDCAR.R04, June 18-21. Storrs, CT: Roper Center for Public Opinion Research.
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|
 |
|
  M. A. Peterson The Truth about Health Care: Why Reform Is Not Working in America; The Health Care Mess: How We Got Into It and What It Will Take to Get Out; The Health Care Mess: How We Got Into It and How We'll Get Out of It Journal of Health Politics Policy and Law, January 1, 2008; 33(2): 343 - 357. [Abstract] [PDF]
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
